Monday, February 18, 2013

Blue Jay Monday: One of the "lost" Blue Jays, Joey Hamilton

One of the positive things about starting to get my Blue Jays collection sorted and into binders is I've come across quite a few cards of Jays that I had even forgotten were part of the club.

Rick Leach.  Orlando Merced.  Juan Beniquez.  Jeff Burroughs.  I could go on and on.  I call them the "lost" Blue Jays, because you know these guys well from their careers with other major league clubs, and their time in Toronto just seems to be lost in the shuffle.

These are guys that had brief stays with the team, often times just for a pennant run.  Rickey Henderson in '93 is a prime example. 

Every once in a while, I'll dig up one of these cards and try to write a brief post on what kind of effect the player had on the team.  The card I found for you tonight is...

1999 Upper Deck #518, Joey Hamilton.  What made me select this card first?  The red cap of course.  It's amazing what a little thing like an off colored cap will do to trigger the memory. 

A former first round draft choice of the San Diego Padres in 1991, Joey Hamilton spent all of the 1999 & 2000 seasons with Toronto, and pitched until August of 2001 before finally being released.  Why do I say finally?  Let's just say that Joey's stats with the Blue Jays were less than stellar.

The Jays had acquired him from San Diego in December of 1998 to replace the soon to be departing Roger Clemens.  It didn't work out that well.  The '99 season was just brutal, with a 6.52 ERA in just 18 starts.  Little did the Jays know that they had a young kid who would be starting a great career, Roy Halladay.

The 2000 season was a total wash, with Joey only making 6 starts with a 2-1 record.  In 2001, his stats went right back to the mediocrity he showed in 1999.  A 5-8 record, 5.89 ERA and 1.700 WHIP (!) led the Jays to finally cut the cord and release Joey at the beginning of August.  Oh, and opponents were hitting .346 against him.  Yikes.

Joey went on to finish his career with Cincinnati, pitching from 2001-2003 with no more success than he had with the Blue Jays.  A lot of the problems that Joey had over the final 6 seasons of his career appear to have stemmed from him losing a lot of the zip off of his fastball. 

Meet the first of the "lost" Blue Jays, Joey Hamilton.

thanks for reading, Robert


  1. Man, I had no idea Joey was that bad after he left San Diego! I think he was our Opening Day starter for a few years, and he left SD after five years with a decent 55-44 record and a 3.83 ERA. He was a big part of the few great teams the Padres had (in 1996 and 1998). Guess things didn't quite work out after he left.

  2. The dark days of the Jays.

    Orlando Merced? I didn't even know about that one...

  3. This is another example of a Gord Ash trade that didn't work out as planned. Hamilton was supposed to be the ace of the staff. Ash gave up Woody Williams to get Hamilton. Williams had an ok career and was still pitching by the time Hamilton was finished. Hindsight being 20:20 Ash had either constant bad luck with his trades or should have been fired sooner than he was for making bad moves. He is a lot better as an AGM than a GM.